Skip to main content
difficult employees

How Do You Handle Difficult Employees: Steps That Work

How Do You Handle Difficult Employees? A fair, documented process for owners: prepare, talk, set clear expectations, follow up and know when to get help.

By Glenis Gassmann, Implementation-Focused Business Advisor11 min read
How Do You Handle Difficult Employees: Steps That Work

You've spoken to the same employee again. They agreed to improve, but the next missed deadline landed on your desk anyway. Now you're checking their work, smoothing things over with colleagues and wondering whether keeping them is harder than replacing them.

So, how do you handle difficult employees without becoming their permanent supervisor? Check the person, the standard and your own follow-through before deciding what to do. A better conversation won't fix unclear instructions or a review meeting you keep postponing.

The task is to identify the gap, give the employee a fair chance to respond and follow through on a clear decision.

Table of Contents

Work Out Whether the Person or the System Is the Problem

Missed deadlines, repeated mistakes, pushback in meetings and a sharp tone with colleagues require different responses. Calling them all difficult can hide whether the problem lies in capability, conduct or the way the work is organised.

Symptoms, likely causes and the first check

SymptomLikely causeFirst check
Several staff hitting the same problemUnclear standard or heavy workloadReview the process and workload before the person
Change in behaviour after a restructure or new managerChange not explained or support missingCheck role clarity and the support given
Missed deadlines, rework or repeated errorsCapability, unclear instructions or overloadAsk what they need and check their current load
Raised voices, sarcasm or humiliating colleaguesConduct or bullying issueRecord incidents now and treat it as a conduct and safety matter
Disagreeing with decisions in meetingsDifferent view expressed poorlySeparate the disagreement from the way it is expressed
Sudden shift alongside personal stressHealth or personal matterAsk an open question and check your policy before acting

This is a triage tool, not a verdict. If several people stumble at the same task, examine the process. If one employee's conduct harms colleagues, address it promptly. Someone who challenges a decision might have a useful point even when their delivery needs correcting.

Check the setup you expect them to succeed in

Look at the instructions, access, authority and workload. If an employee owns a task but every decision still needs your approval, you've given them responsibility without the authority to deliver.

Review your business systems and processes (opens in new tab) when the same failure appears across different people. A workflow that relied on you checking everything may no longer suit the business.

Ask: Could a reasonable person in this role meet the standard with the same tools, training and information? If not, fix the setup as part of the response.

How to Prepare Before You Speak to Them

Prepare a short factual account the employee can understand and answer. You want to establish what happened and what needs to change, not deliver a verdict before hearing their explanation.

Replacement workplace infographic. Exact heading: "How to Prepare Before You Speak to Them". Three clearly numbered pane
  1. Write the gap in a sentence. State what's happening, what should happen instead and since when. Three client replies missed the agreed reply window last fortnight is useful; bad attitude isn't.
  2. Gather dates and specifics. Bring relevant emails, task records, complaints and notes, including who was affected and what you've tried. Distinguish what you observed from what someone reported. An allegation is not an established fact.
  3. Check the rules that apply. Read the relevant policy, employment contract, applicable award and earlier written expectations. Check that the requirement was communicated before enforcing it.
  4. Test consistency. Compare the last similar case. If another employee received training for the same error, identify why this case warrants a different response.
  5. Decide the outcome you want. Draft an observable standard, realistic support and a proposed review date. Remain open to information that changes your assessment.
  6. Choose the time and place. Arrange a private meeting with enough time for a response. Explain its purpose and check any support-person requirements with your HR adviser.

Bring a page, not a prosecution file

Put the gap, evidence, expected standard, support and proposed review date on one page. Keep supporting records available without turning every past irritation into part of the case.

Practical rule
Preparation test: If you can't describe acceptable performance, you're not ready to tell someone they're falling short.

Include your contribution. Did priorities change without a new deadline? Was promised training delivered? A fair discussion accounts for those facts too.

Set Standards You Can Measure and Record

Examples of measurable standards and review points

These are examples to adapt, not legal thresholds or universal workplace benchmarks.

GapMeasurable standardReview point
Slow replies to clientsReply within one business dayWeekly check of the client inbox
Repeated order errorsFewer than two errors a week in order entryFortnightly review of the error log
Late startsNo more than one late start in a fortnightFortnightly attendance check
Conduct toward colleaguesNo raised voices or personal comments in team meetingsWeekly review plus the incident log
Incomplete handoverWritten handover completed before end of shiftWeekly sign-off by the team lead

Name the manager responsible for each check so the work doesn't automatically return to you. Both people should be able to tell whether the standard was met. Be more positive doesn't meet that test. No raised voices or personal comments describes conduct you can record. Note what was said or done, not your opinion of the employee's personality.

Give improvement a reasonable window

The Fair Work Ombudsman's managing underperformance guide (opens in new tab) refers to a typical improvement period of six to eight weeks, not a universal legal deadline. Choose a period that fits the issue, role and time reasonably needed to assess improvement.

Schedule checkpoints to inspect the work, confirm promised support and address barriers. Record what happens. The Fair Work final warning template (opens in new tab) records the issue, discussion, employer support, required action and reasonable timeframe for improvement.

  • Support promised: Specify the training, clearer instructions or workload adjustment, and who will deliver it.
  • Employee action: Record what must change and how you'll check it.
  • Possible consequences: Explain what may happen if the standard isn't met.

Give the employee a copy and an opportunity to respond. Connect the measures to business performance (opens in new tab), such as fewer corrections or complete handovers. Book the decision meeting for a calendar date rather than leaving it as sometime next month.

Have the Conversation Without Making It Worse

State the specific concern near the start. For a late order, identify its recorded due date, when it was completed and the effect of the delay. Explain the expected process, including when to flag a deadline at risk. Calm and direct beats a long, vague opening.

Two people in a calm, private one-to-one conversation across a desk in an Australian workplace. The manager is listening

Use plain language that fits the evidence. State what you know, distinguish it from what has been reported and leave room for the employee to explain.

Ask, then stop talking

Ask what got in the way. Check instructions, workload, access and skills, then listen for information that could change your understanding of the cause.

Keep questions about health or personal circumstances open and respectful. Focus on relevant work limitations and support needs, not private details unrelated to the task.

Practical rule
You can take an explanation seriously without accepting that the behaviour should continue.

If the employee becomes upset, pause without abandoning the concern. If they dispute the facts, ask what's missing, record the disagreement and check any new evidence.

Leave with a clear next action

Ask the employee to explain what must change and by when. This checks whether you've communicated clearly.

Before you finish, confirm:

  • The action: What the employee will do differently.
  • The support: What you or the manager will provide.
  • The review: The calendar date and evidence you'll examine.

Send a written summary promptly, ideally by the next working day, and invite factual corrections. Tell colleagues only what changes operationally, not the employee's explanation or any disciplinary detail.

If the employee complains about your conduct or bullying, pause, record the complaint and seek advice on handling it separately. Don't investigate your own alleged behaviour while finishing the performance discussion.

Decide the Next Step Based on the Results

Review outcome, next step and check before acting

Review outcomeNext stepCheck before acting
Standard met for the full periodClose the plan and keep the notesNone beyond the record
Partial progress with real effortExtend the plan with narrower targetsConfirm the promised support was delivered
Standard not met after a fair periodWritten warning naming the issue and timeframeEmployee has heard the concern and had a chance to respond
Standard still not met after a written warningFinal warning or proposed terminationWritten reasons given and a genuine chance to respond
Serious misconduct or immediate safety riskUrgent action under your policyGet advice before acting

This is a decision guide, not an automatic disciplinary ladder. Match the response to the evidence, circumstances and applicable employment requirements. If the standard has been met, close the plan and return to ordinary supervision. Don't move the finish line because the original problem still frustrates you.

Don't confuse a warning count with a fair process

The Fair Work Ombudsman's performance guidance (opens in new tab) says there's no automatic requirement for three warnings, or even one, before ending employment for performance or conduct reasons, but you still need a valid reason and a fair process. Termination is a final resort, not the opening move.

Australian guidance doesn't replace New Zealand employment advice. If your employee works in New Zealand, get local advice before formal action.

Before an adverse decision, verify the employee's explanation and compare the outcome with similar cases. Identify any relevant difference rather than relying on frustration.

Practical rule
A review meeting is for deciding what the evidence supports, not announcing a decision already made.

Watch for these traps:

  • Protecting the high performer: Strong sales or technical skills don't cancel out harmful conduct.
  • Punishing disagreement: A different view isn't automatically bullying or insubordination.
  • Reverting to labels: Difficult and negative don't explain the specific failure.
  • Acting from exhaustion: Being tired of the problem doesn't replace evidence or a fair opportunity to respond.

Repeated extensions deserve scrutiny too. If promised support was delivered and the gap remains, an open-ended promise is not a decision. Consistent standards are part of sound staff retention strategies (opens in new tab) for the rest of the team. Before dismissal, take the records to an employment lawyer or appropriately qualified employment adviser.

Decide Whether to Bring in Outside Help Now

Use your records to estimate the hours you and your managers spent correcting the work over the past six months. Add rework, credits and delayed jobs. Consider what your team has stopped raising and which decisions you keep postponing. The point isn't to invent a neat total; it's to see whether the same unresolved issue will keep costing time.

Match the help to the problem

Use an HR adviser if you haven't run this process before, an employment lawyer before dismissal, and your accountant where pay or entitlements are in question.

When similar problems keep returning through different employees, examine the standard and your follow-through as well as the individual case. Your next change may be clearer delegation or a decision you've delayed, not another round of supervision.

The Business X-ray is a free diagnostic session where Glenis Gassmann goes through your actual numbers with you and shows where profit is leaking and where the business depends on you. There's no obligation and nothing to prepare. It's a conversation, not a pitch. Book the Business X-ray at yoursuccessshift.com (opens in new tab).

Not ready to talk? Read Glenis Gassmann's Why Knowing Isn't Enough (opens in new tab), a number one Amazon new release. Knowing you need to have the conversation is not the same as having it.

Stop Knowing. Start Doing.

Glenis Gassmann is an Implementation-Driven Business Advisor on the Gold Coast, working with established business owners across Australia and New Zealand. Author of Why Knowing Isn't Enough, a number one Amazon new release.

Topics

Managing difficult staff, Employee performance issues, HR process Australia, Handling staff conflict

Ready to turn insight into action?

Book a free call with Glenis to discuss your goals.